Monday, February 18, 2013

Canadian Senate Reformers Should Not Cite The Australian Senate

Advocates of Senate reform (particularly direct election of Canadian Senators) have taken to citing Australia's Senate as evidence that elected and democratically legitimate Senates are compatible with well run societies (here, here and here).  They should desist, unless they are prepared to advocate for an actual Australian model Senate, which is quite different from the one they are proposing for Canada.

Australia's Senate is Elected by Proportional Representation

This is almost certainly the most important difference.  Canadian Senate reformers are advocating Senators be elected by Province in the same manner we elect House members - first past the post.  How that would play out in multi-party Canada is unclear, though likely it would continue to allow a plurality support party to win a majority of Senate seats.  I fail to see how two Houses of Parliament elected by the same system improve Canadian democracy.

Australia's Senate has Limited Powers

Australia's Senate is not allowed to originate or (this is key) amend Supply bills.  This means the Government's budget bills (from the House of Commons) are take-it-or-leave-it propositions.  The US Senate is supposedly prevented from originating such bills, but with the power to amend them, this limitation proves essentially useless.  The US Senate, when it wants to pass such a bill, just takes any old House bill already passed that chamber, and "amends" it by stripping its contents and substituting a new bill.  Canada's Constitution has a US style provision and I expect it would be equally ineffectual without an Australian style limitation on amendment powers to money bills.

Australia's House has Powers to Override the Senate

For brevity's sake get the details here, but briefly the Prime Minister has some ability in extreme circumstances of the Senate blocking something, to force full elections of the entire Parliament and if that still doesn't get a Senate willing to pass whatever bill, the PM can initiate a joint sitting where House and Senate members get 1 vote each, and the much greater number of House members will probably cause the measure to prevail.  The first power (double dissolution) has been used six times already, and the joint sitting power was needed only once, to bring in Australia's system of universal health care during the 1970s.

The regular need for these override powers even given the extremity of causing an additional full national election campaign to do it should caution Senate reformers as to the general obstructionist nature of Senates that have the power to behave that way.  In a Canada that had the Senate our reformers are pushing, could national universal health care have come to be?

Still, even these limited powers and capacity for override did not prevent the Australian 1975 Constitutional Crisis where the Senate was blocking supply to the government, and the Governor-General decided he was therefore required to dismiss the Prime Minister (who still had confidence of the House) and force new elections.  A person on Twitter asked me if one crisis means their entire system is unworthy, and my answer is "maybe" - it depends how bad the crisis is, or could have been. That crisis was not only about the role of the Senate, but the unelected Governor-General dismissing a Prime Minister but we would be foolish not to observe that incident and ensure it could not happen in our system.

It would be an exaggeration to say Australia is some kind of failure.  It's a prosperous country and ahead of Canada in a number of developmental areas.  Yet it's clear that their Senate is nothing like the one reformers are pushing for Canada so we really can't draw much on their experience, and even then they have had significant troubles with their model.  I maintain my belief that the most sensible reform is abolition of the chamber, but if reform must be, I would vastly prefer the Australian model of a more democratically elected Senate, with limited legislative powers and which can be overridden at need to the model being pushed for Canada.

39 comments:

  1. Gambling is one amongst the most eminent sources of entertainment today. It is also the cause of livelihood for many people. Gambling is all about wagering money usually to acquire more wealth or even things of material significance river slots

    ReplyDelete
  2. The internet webcam technology has brought live casino games to the desktop. It enables you to play your favorite's casino games with similar experience and excitement as at the land-based casino from your computer. รีวิวคาสิโนufabet

    ReplyDelete
  3. By popular demand, online flash games have become the rave of all ages for creating a positive online experience. Online flash games are exciting, addictive, promote family bonding and relieve stress. The many genres of flash games will surely make you want to play on your free time or with your children for great no cost fun. 바카라 사이트

    ReplyDelete
  4. Do you believe that it is possible to win the lottery? Can you really use a lottery system to land the big prizes? Most people think that you cannot. 파워볼 사이트

    ReplyDelete
  5. Playing the lottery is indeed very exciting isn't it? It is a game of chance that could make you quite wealthy if you happen to hit the jackpot and you do not even have to spend too much money in order to pay for your lottery tickets. But did you know that you can now play lottery games through several online sites? 파워볼

    ReplyDelete
  6. HANABET adalah situs slot online terpercaya yang menyediakan platform judi online terbaik kami memberikan odds termurah untuk Taruhan bola situs slot online terpercaya

    ReplyDelete
  7. So, you would like to find out how to win the lottery guaranteed? Are there really strategies that can guarantee you to win? ตรวจลอตเตอรี่

    ReplyDelete
  8. An analysis of casino gaming revenue across the U.S. for 2008. It has been a period of adjustment for casinos, as they cope with declining demand and escalating competition. mega888 free credit rm10 2020

    ReplyDelete
  9. The topic is about the cooking classes that develop the ability of cooking. It also tells about various courses offered in cooking class and the role of libraries in cooking. It spins around the fact that cooking is an endless course and even experienced people has got many things to learn to make them more efficient than they are. https://prometeolibros.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have to say that this is really a good influencing look at this particular subject matter. I’m really pleased you shared your thoughts plus smart ideas and I discovered I somewhat agree. I seriously like your clear writing additionally , the efforts you might have used writing this submit. Numerous thanks yous for your strong work and very good luck with your blog, I most certainly will be awaiting new articles within the future. buy HGH

    ReplyDelete
  11. There's no denying that video games have become an integral part of the millennial life. This is probably because they allow the gamer to lead an alternate life, full of adventure and challenges. Gaming is a truly global industry today- a $60 billion one. pussy888

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just love to read new topics from you blog.~~~`” double sided tape

    ReplyDelete
  13. There's no denying that video games have become an integral part of the millennial life. This is probably because they allow the gamer to lead an alternate life, full of adventure and challenges. Gaming is a truly global industry today- a $60 billion one. 188bet

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you for yet another great informative post, I’m a loyal visitor to this blog and I can’t tell you how much valuable information I’ve learned from reading your content. I really appreciate all the hard work you put into this great blog. Buy steroids online

    ReplyDelete
  15. Online casino games have become tremendously popular thanks to the spread of the internet. Online casinos can be divided into three groups based on their interface: web-based casinos, download-based casinos, and more recently live casinos. Read the article to know more about online casinos บาคาร่า sa

    ReplyDelete
  16. In the world there are thousands of internet casinos. How not to get lost in the richness of choice, is it possible to find a way to systematize this diversity? Yes you can. The fact that there are several companies who are professionally engaged in manufacturing software for the casino. Slot Online

    ReplyDelete
  17. Immigration… [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]… hgh for sale

    ReplyDelete
  18. Las Vegas, Nevada, is the world's greatest gambling city in the world. The most famous casinos are located at the South end of the Las Vegas Boulevard, the Strip. Most of the casinos are connected to large hotels or resorts. Besides the famous casinos at the strip, there are also some glamorous casinos at the Fremont Street Experience in Downtown Las Vegas. Slot Online

    ReplyDelete
  19. Casinos are a place where in you can feature the highest quality gambling activities and its emergence has made online casinos a very realistic term. Now you can feature high quality casino games by just sitting in the comfort zone of your home. These online games are many a times known as virtual casino games or internet casino games. https://totostrong.com/메이저사이트

    ReplyDelete
  20. In the gaming world, there are several options to choose from when it comes to the platform the game is being played on. There are PC games, and there are console games. The difference lies within the way the game is played. bandar slot online

    ReplyDelete
  21. So you've decided to plunge yourself into the world of game development, have assembled a team of mighty warriors to tackle all the big issues and are ready to create the next best game in the industry... trumping WoW, Guild Wars... (you get the point). You've chopped up all your brainstorming and assembled some really keen concepts for a storyline and you're ready to go. But amongst all the programming, the character concepts, the dungeons, and the quests - what are truly the most important aspects of your game that will determine whether someone enjoys themself? Read on, and allow me to share with you what I think. slot online terpercaya

    ReplyDelete
  22. In the gaming world, there are several options to choose from when it comes to the platform the game is being played on. There are PC games, and there are console games. The difference lies within the way the game is played. learn free here

    ReplyDelete
  23. If you love the thrill of gambling in live casinos then you will be excited to learn that you can play all of your favorite casino games online! Online casinos are rapidly growing in popularity as gambling enthusiasts around the globe are realizing that they can play online casino games twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week from the comfort of their very own homes. judi online

    ReplyDelete
  24. Worker placement games have been very popular the past decade with games like Agricola, Caylus and Stone Age setting the standards high. With "Lords of Waterdeep", Wizards of the Coast attempts to enter the area of Eurogames and stir the waters, by delivering a high quality game, set in the "Dungeons & Dragons" universe. Let's see how successful this attempt is. daftar slot online

    ReplyDelete
  25. I took some time to write a simple list about all the Wii games that are compatible with the Wii Balance Board (Wii Fit Board). The article includes a small summary for each of the 48 games. slot online terpercaya sultan lido

    ReplyDelete
  26. You might have noticed that there are many more video games store today compared to twenty years ago. The main reason for this is that the industry of video games and video game accessories has boomed all over the world in the past two decades. Many of these video games store don't just sell newly released games but they also sell old and used video games making it affordable to all video game players including those who are on a tight budget. daftar live22 indonesia

    ReplyDelete
  27. An important part to nearly every video game is the characters present in the game. Players need fun characters that they can identify with to keep the game exciting and interesting. live22 deposit pulsa

    ReplyDelete
  28. Worker placement games have been very popular the past decade with games like Agricola, Caylus and Stone Age setting the standards high. With "Lords of Waterdeep", Wizards of the Coast attempts to enter the area of Eurogames and stir the waters, by delivering a high quality game, set in the "Dungeons & Dragons" universe. Let's see how successful this attempt is. 먹튀검증커뮤니티

    ReplyDelete
  29. When you are looking for a mobile game download, you are going to find that for every true gem on the market, there will be a sea of titles that quickly end up erased off your device. While you sometimes get lucky and the mistake is only a free mobile game, there are some paid downloads that should have spent more time in the development stages. On this list, you will find the best mobile games that are currently available joker99

    ReplyDelete
  30. The world of Mobile Phone games is filled with mediocrity. I thought that it was impossible to find a game that could compete with a full console or PC game, but then I tried "Game Dev Story"... joker99

    ReplyDelete
  31. A wide portion of browser-based games are based on Java and Flash technologies. That is why they are most commonly known as "flash games". During the past years, online flash games have become increasingly popular due to several reasons derived from three major factors: they are accessible, diverse and affordable. slot online

    ReplyDelete
  32. Among all the games available for the PC today, by far the most addictive of them all are Puzzle Games. These games can keep you glued to your computer for hours on end as you strive to complete all levels to reach the end. Curiosity gets the better of commonsense and you will find grown up adults skipping meals even just to complete a puzzle. daftar rekomendasi situs slot online terpercaya

    ReplyDelete
  33. Regards for all your efforts that you have put in this. Very interesting information. 먹튀검증커뮤니티

    ReplyDelete
  34. Have you noticed the news has changed its approach recently? What used to neve be brought up or discussed has changed. It’s that time to chagnge our stance on this though. 토토커뮤니티

    ReplyDelete
  35. plumbing can really be a hardwork specially if you are not very skillfull in doing home plumbing:: 먹튀검증커뮤니티

    ReplyDelete
  36. Have you heard of freezer cooking? It's a great way to save time and money while eating healthier meals at home! TOS885 Login Slot

    ReplyDelete
  37. When only the flavor of onions is desired in a salad or a cooked dish of some sort, such as a dressing for fowl, hash, or any similar combination of food ingredients, the onion should be added in the form of juice and pulp rather than in pieces. Then it will not be possible to observe the onion when it is mixed with the food nor to come across small pieces of it when the food is eaten. To prepare an onion in this way, peel it, cut off a crosswise slice, and then grate the onion on a grater. Daftar Judi Bola Online,

    ReplyDelete
  38. People all around the world play games online or have interest in playing different games while sitting online in front of the computer screens. Usually the online games people play is through Facebook apps or other social networking web sites. Playing online game is a very interesting and entertaining time pass and helps kill the boredom when there is nothing to do. Situs Judi Bola Online

    ReplyDelete
  39. Is it possible to monetize on a Flash games website? Why this internet money making idea may not be such a good one. bokep terbaru

    ReplyDelete